In Hebrew, “manna” isn’t just the name of miraculous bread that rains from heaven. It’s actually a question: “Man-na?” Literally, the word means, “What the heck is this?” The fine flakey stuff God gave the ancient Israelites to eat in the desert was amazing yet also quite weird. It took work to figure out what it was, whether it was safe to eat, and how well it would nourish the people. Manna was just enough for today, and no more. When manna was hoarded it spoiled. This food was designed to show a formerly enslaved nation how to embody the essentials of freedom—trust and rest.
For a while now (though not 40 years) I’ve been wandering in the wilderness of our First Church history. The journey began two summers ago when we moved the archives to make way for the offices of Southeast Seniors. It was a steamy week in the middle of summer. Sweat rolled down our faces, dust coated our skin, and we labored long to schlep valuable items and total junk alike to its new home. Since then, I confess I’ve been a little obsessed, particularly with our founding pastor and earliest years. I’ve probed letters, articles, and internet sources, like a detective on the hunt for juicy evidence. What is this? I’ve wondered again and again. What is the story here? What does it mean?
In Rev. Seccombe’s letters chronicling the first few years of his ministry there’s not much about the community beyond the church—except for his accounts of a march and convention related to the temperance movement. His work with abolition apparently came later. There’s a lot in his letters about the struggles of working with the Presbyterians and the trials of raising funds to build “a house” for worship. He describes in detail how he managed to purchase singing books for the choir. In just a few brief, agonized words he recounts the deaths of both his infant child and his first wife. Seccombe’s reports completely erase native people, and ignore their intimate and sacred relationship with the land he’s inhabiting. In this, he was simply a person of his time, and not at all unique.
Robert Jones puts it this way in The Hidden Roots of White Supremacy, “The Doctrine of Discovery furnished the foundational lie that America was ‘discovered’ […] Ideas such as Manifest Destiny, America as a city on a hill, or America as the new Zion all sprouted from the seed that was planted in 1493. This sense of divine entitlement, of European Christian chosenness, has shaped the worldview of most white Americans and thereby influenced key events, policies, and laws throughout American history.”
And in the preface to their powerful work, So We and Our Children May Live, Sarah Augustine and Sheri Hostetler point out the ongoing consequences of these legal and political structures. “We are fighting to dismantle structures designed to remove Indigenous Peoples from their land so that our economic systems can continue to extract and consume resources at an ever-increasing pace. This growth-based system, designed to generate wealth and profits for individuals, is threatening the survival of all life on this planet. […] Extraction and the pollution it causes are now pushing us past several planetary boundaries, including carbon dioxide emissions in the atmosphere. In short, extraction is devastating the life-support systems of our planet.”
This death-dealing legacy is one true story about what we’ve inherited over these past 175 years. And at the same time, there are many other true stories about those who came before us. Stories about the people who sat in these pews, their everyday kindness and quiet service, the ways they tended grief and loved the children who grew up here. How they wrestled with new ideas, their conflicts and compromises, the music and art they created, the ways they have stood up and spoken out, their generosity and sacrifice. Our job on this anniversary, I think, is to honor and tell all the stories, to let each of the truths be true.
When truth is complex and contradictory, then we can receive God’s gift of manna, which provokes that nourishing and holy question, “What is this?” We can continue to learn, to reflect, to become something new. And maybe someday when we hear about the promised land we will be able to live in such a way that demonstrates: land is not a possession or a commodity, land is a living community of mutuality. And perhaps if the voice of God gently reminds us, “I belong with you, and you belong with me,” we will not try to make our unique way of being with God into the only way. And as we respond to the call of our founders, to “let our light shine” we will repudiate the cold glare of superiority, and the arsonous blaze of greed. We will be one twinkle on a long string of little lights, one warm and generous blaze on a hillside full of campfires. When we shine, the world will see the humble ways of Jesus reflected, instead of the dominating posture of empire. We will be a lamp of wisdom, a beacon of neighbor-love a spark of respectful cross-cultural collaboration. We will keep the lights on together with people who pray differently or not at all. We will work with our community partners to stop the hamster wheel of extraction and to build new systems of care, resilience and rest.
Forgive me for introducing yet one more metaphor; I love the hymn we’re about to sing for the beautiful way it describes the church we are yearning to become. “May this church be like a tree.” Like a living being. Rooted in the earth, open to the air, freely giving shelter and rest, sharing the water that gives life the water of Haha Wakpa, the water of baptism, turning the light of the sun into food for the world. Amen.